Identity vs. Behaviour: The problem with labels in addiction

Words like junkie, addict, alcoholic, crackhead, and abuser share a common flaw: they reduce a person's entire existence to a single behaviour or condition. They place the person as the problem, rather than someone engaged in a behaviour that is causing harm.

Identity-level language tends to create defensiveness and disengagement. It also implies permanence: if this is who I am, I'm stuck with it for life.

Clinical research confirms this. A study published in the Journal of Drug Issues found that clinicians exposed to the term "substance abuser" demonstrated significantly higher negative bias — viewing the individual as personally culpable and more deserving of punishment — compared to when the same person was described as having a "substance use disorder" (Kelly & Westerhoff, 2010). If trained professionals are affected by this linguistic framing, the impact on a vulnerable person is likely even greater.

The Trap of Clean vs. Dirty

Terms like clean and dirty — commonly used to describe toxicology results or recovery status — introduce a binary moral framework: right vs. wrong, good vs. bad. Describing a test result as "dirty" or praising someone for being "clean" implies that the person was morally deficient while using substances.

There is a widespread belief that increasing pressure and shame will motivate change — that people must hit "rock bottom" before they're ready to recover. In reality, shame-based motivation rarely holds. The cycle looks like this:

1. Pressure builds, and the person changes their behaviour to escape the pain of stigma.
2. The immediate tension releases as behaviour shifts.
3. Without positive motivators or alternative coping skills, substance use resurfaces.
4. The pressure builds again.

Moralistic language enforces rigidity and drains the emotional energy a person needs to build a genuinely different life. Lasting recovery rarely comes from increasing internal tension — it comes from safely addressing the underlying pain, trauma, or unmet need driving the behaviour.

A guide for family and friends navigating addiction

"The person I care about is downplaying their behavior. How do I get through to them?"

Before trying to "get through" to someone, it's worth pausing to ask what you're actually trying to achieve — and whether the language you're using is moving you closer to them or further away.

When a loved one minimises their substance use, empathy is more effective than confrontation. Consider your own experiences of denial: it often feels safer to downplay a problem than to face the risk of failing to change it. It is entirely common — and deeply human — to want to change and want to stay the same at the same time.

"Conflict feels like the only language they respond to. What else can I do?"

The antidote to shame-driven tension is choice. For many people, substance use has been their most reliable tool for managing overwhelming circumstances, even at significant cost to themselves and others. Learning new ways of coping is unfamiliar and frightening. People are far more likely to consider new

What to say instead

According to guidelines from the National Institute on Drug Abuse, person-first language — which frames the person as having a problem rather than being one — reduces stigma and improves quality of care.

How you frame a statement matters just as much as the words themselves:

• "You are abusing substances" — positions the person as the problem; invites defensiveness.
• "I've noticed an increase in your substance use and I'm concerned" — expresses your experience and opens dialogue.

Words are also inseparable from tone, posture, and facial expression. If you hold judgment or anger, it will communicate itself regardless of how carefully you choose your words. Grounding yourself in genuine compassion before you speak is not a small thing — it's often the most important part of the conversation.

Shifting away from stigmatising language takes time and deliberate practice. But by changing the words we use, we lower barriers to help, preserve the dignity of the people we love, and create more space for connection and real recovery.

If you or a loved one is navigating addiction or substance use, you can use our online chat to speak directly to a qualified counsellor or join one of our community support groups and connect with others who are going through similar journeys.

If you’re struggling with gambling, visit Gambling Help Online for free and confidential specialised support and advise available 24/7.